Our opinions on public issues are often shaped by “experts.” But are they really expert? How can we know?
Terry Newell is currently director of his own firm, Leadership for a Responsible Society. His work focuses on values-based leadership, ethics, and decision making. A former Air Force officer, Terry also previously served as Director of the Horace Mann Learning Center, the training arm of the U.S. Department of Education, and as Dean of Faculty at the Federal Executive Institute. Terry is co-editor and author of The Trusted Leader: Building the Relationships That Make Government Work (CQ Press, 2011). He also wrote Statesmanship, Character and Leadership in America (Palgrave Macmillan, 2013) and To Serve with Honor: Doing the Right Thing in Government (Loftlands Press 2015).
All in Civic Virtue
Our opinions on public issues are often shaped by “experts.” But are they really expert? How can we know?
Good political arguments are essential in a democracy. Too many Americans don’t have the skills needed.
When we “cancel” the freedom to speak, we damage the learning, debate and persuasion essential to a free society.
Americans who divide themselves from their countrymen for selfish interests, ideology and political gain ignore our founders hopes, weakening the national union on which our freedom depends.
On the surface, lotteries to encourage COVID vaccination seem like a great idea. Below the surface, it’s useful to raise some questions.
We are genetically designed to care about others. A healthy society needs to find ways to foster such caring because culture can get in the way.
People anchor political arguments in “public opinion.” Yet public opinion is often manufactured by those with a political axe to grind. Citizens must think for themselves and be wary of following “public opinion.”
A healthy society balances individual freedom with personal responsibility.
The American experiment in self-government is based on the power of reason to restrain dangerous passions. The attack on the U.S. Capitol is a troubling sign that that restraint is failing.
A year of profound tragedy and disruption, 2020 was also a time American moral heroes, doing their jobs and honoring their values, showed us the best of who we are and can be.
Sloppy reporting on social media is damaging America. The way to stop its spread is better thinking.
Billions are spent on candidate ads, most of which are negative. They impact the vote almost negligibly but they may well hurt society.
We’re often too reluctant to just say “I don’t know.” The result is uninformed opinions and ineffective public debate.
It’s natural to apply labels to ideas and people. But this convenient shorthand can cause problems, damaging our need to respect and work with others.
Fake news is everywhere, but alertness and reason can defeat its intended impact.
Saying “I was wrong” opens the door to personal learning, healing, and better relationships - for individuals and leaders.
Acting as if we can either save the economy or save lives is a false ethical choice. We can do both. What we may lack is the will.
It may be natural to think in “us vs. them” terms, but that tendency can be overcome when seeing “them” as really part of “us” is good for everyone.
As humans, we have an innate tendency to think in “us” vs. “them” terms. Culture can soften or exacerbate that inclination.
Evidence that three administrations have been lying to the public about the war in Afghanistan has been met mostly with Congressional and public apathy. This is dangerous for our troops - and democracy.